Thursday, December 9, 2010

The following is an interesting summary of a study done on errors in research design: Empirical Evidence of Prevalence of Methodological Problems in Published Reports of Randomized Trials (Altman, 2002).


Failing to specify eligibility criteria
                25% of 364 reports in surgery journals
Not reporting an adequate method for generating random numbers
                68% of 206 reports in OB/GYN journals; 52% of 80 reports in general medicine journals
Not reporting the mechanism used to allocate interventions
89% of 196 reports in rheumatoid arthritis journals, 48% of 206 reports in OB/GYN Journals;  44% of 80 reports in general medicine journals
Failing to state whether blinding was used
51% of 506 in cystic fibrosis journals, 33% of 196 reports in rheumatoid arthritis journals; 38% of 68 reports in dermatology journals
Incorrect analysis of multiple observations
                63% of 196 reports in rheumatoid arthritis journals
Inadequate information on harmful consequences of interventions
                61% of 192 reports in 7 medical areas
Incorrect method of comparison of subgroups
                58% of 50 reports in general journals
References:
Altman, G. (2002, June). Poor quality medical research.  JAMA. 287(21). 2765-2767

No comments:

Post a Comment

Pages